PID loop controller for Node-RED
A Node-RED node which operates as a PID loop controller node intended for the control of real world processes.
Run the following command in the root directory of your Node-RED install
npm install node-red-contrib-pid
Pass the node a process value in msg.payload at regular intervals and configure (or pass in via a message) a setpoint and tuning parameters and the algorithm will generate a required power output between 0 and 1 in msg.payload using a Proportional+Integral+Derivative algorithm.
Any message received with a msg.topic other than those defined below is assumed to contain the current process value in msg.payload and the control algorithm will be run, passing on the required power in msg.payload.
The properties below can also be set using msg.---. For example, to change the setpoint you can set the message attribute msg.setpoint to the required value. Using this method, it is possible to set multiple PID properties using the same message. When using this method to set the properties msg.payload should contain the process value.
Example and Tuning Guide
A sample flow demonstrating usage is available at http://flows.nodered.org/flow/42f125b56a00dd5d1433c2f8023263e9
A tuning guide that walks through a simple tuning procedure using the above flow is available at http://blog.clanlaw.org.uk/pid-loop-tuning.html
Setpoint - This is the process value that the process is aiming for. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
setpointand msg.payload set to the required floating point value.
Proportional band - This controls the gain of the loop and is the range of process value over which the power output will go from 0 to full power. The units are that of the process and setpoint, so for example in a heating application it might be set to 1.5 degrees. If set to zero then control becomes On/Off with zero hysteresis. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
prop_bandand msg.payload set to the required floating point value.
Integral time - This is a setting for the integral time, in seconds. It represents the time constant of the integration effect. The larger the value the slower the integral effect will be. Obviously the slower the process is the larger this should be. For example for a domestic room heated by convection radiators a setting of one or two hours might be appropriate (in seconds). To disable the integral effect set this to a large number. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
t_integraland msg.payload set to the required integer value.
Derivative time - This is a setting for the derivative time, in seconds. It represents the time constant of the derivative effect. The larger the value the greater will be the derivative effect. Typically this will be set to somewhat less than 25% of the integral setting, once the integral has been adjusted to the optimum value. To disable the derivative effect set this to 0. When initially tuning a loop it is often sensible to start with derivative zero and wind it in once other parameters have been setup. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
t_derivativeand msg.payload set to the required integer value.
Initial integral - This is an initial value which is used to preset the integrated error value when the flow is deployed in order to assist in homing in on the setpoint the first time. It should be set to an estimate of what the power requirement might be in order to maintain the process at the setpoint. For example for a domestic room heating application it might be set to 0.2 indicating that 20% of the available power might be required to maintain the setpoint. The value is of no consequence apart from on deployment of the flow. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
integral_defaultand msg.payload set to the required value. Note that if the property is set via a message then this must be done either before or with the very first process value.
Max sample interval - This is the maximum time in seconds that is expected between samples. It is provided to cope with unusual situations such as a faulty sensor that might prevent the node from being supplied with a process value and to prevent the problem of integral wind-up during that time. Each time a process value is received a check is made on the time since the last sample and if too long has elapsed the integral error term is locked at the previous value and the derivative component is set to zero. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
max_intervaland msg.payload set to the required integer value.
Derivative smoothing factor - In situations where the process sensor has limited resolution (such as the DS18B20), the use of deriviative can be problematic as when the process is changing only slowly the steps in the value cause spikes in the derivative. To reduce the effect of these this parameter can be set to apply a filter to the derivative term. I have found that with the DS18B20 that a value of 3 here can be beneficial, providing effectively a low pass filter on the derivative at 1/3 of the derivative time. This feature may also be useful if the process value is particularly noisy. The smaller the value the greater the filtering effect but the more it will reduce the effectiveness of the derivative. A value of zero disables this feature. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
smooth_factorand msg.payload set to the required value.
Enable state - This is can be used to enable or disable the control (1=enable, 0=disable). When disabled the output is set the value defined in the parameter below. Enable/disable may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
enableand msg.payload set to 1/0 or true/false.
Output power when disabled - This is the value the output is set to when the loop is disabled. It may be setup either in the configuration of the node or by passing the node a message with msg.topic set to
disabled_opand msg.payload set to the required floating point value between 0 and 1.
The status text will normally be empty. In unusual conditions it will show the following values.
Disabled - Control is currently disabled.
Integral Locked - The process is far from the setpoint and the integral term has been locked to prevent integral windup.
Bad PV - The process value passed in is not a number.
Too long since last sample - A long time has elapsed since the last good sample so the integral term will not be accumulated for this sample.
In order to reduce the impact of restarts or redeploys, you can save the integral value in a persistent storage location and feed it back in to the node as it starts. The integral value is available in
msg.integral in the output messages. In order to feed it back in set the
integral_default value to
0.5 -(cached_integral/prop_band) before the first process value is passed in.
Usage with a cooling process
If the process is a cooling process so that when power is applied to the process the process value decreases rather than increases this can be dealt with very easily by passing the output from the node to a Range node configured to convert the range 0:1 to 1:0.
Alternatively if a node-red-contrib-timeprop node is used to generate a time proportioned signal then it is merely necessary to flip the state of the Invert checkbox to achieve the same result.
Usage with a heat/cool process
If the process has both heating and cooling devices then it is necessary to split the output of node-red-contrib-pid to provide a heat output and a cool output. There is a sample flow that demonstrates this at https://flows.nodered.org/flow/4271d6617c89544ad318e7ab17211ba0 This allows for independent adjustment of heat/cool gain and also for heat/cool overlap if required.